MagicDoor Reviews
Total 21 reviews
4.5
All reviews are from verified customers
Rating Distribution
5
Stars86%
4
Stars0%
3
Stars5%
2
Stars0%
1
Stars10%
Satisfaction score
Ease of use
9
Value for money
9
Customer Support
9
Functionality
9
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Won't cancel my subscription!”
Pros
I honestly dont have anything good to say about this tool!!
Cons
Awful experience. I keep contacting them to cancel my subscription but they wait until my card has been charged before sending one email a month saying they hope I'm satisfied.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
1
Value for money
1
Customer Support
1
Functionality
2
Not Specified, N/A employees
“friendly customer service and software”
Pros
Really, I've been impressed with the software and customer service. The staff have been very friendly and helpful, even on the free plan. I'd highly recommend it and look forward to managing my properties in one central place.
Cons
No cons!!
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Commands work smoothly!”
Pros
This is a good software and I love its brand name. The colors are beautiful and its application commands process smoothly.
Cons
Works good, no downsides
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
9
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“quick help for amateur-to-pro results”
Pros
It's a fantastic program that's very simple to use. Whenever I run into an issue, support responds quickly. It's made a huge difference for me and can turn an amateur into a pro.
Cons
I found nothing wrong in it! all went smoothly
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“They have hands-on support”
Pros
Magicdoor brings together a thoughtfully designed platform and a real focus on customer care. From the start, the platform and services were clear and well organized and the whole setup felt designed to simplify the process. The user-focused approach made something that could have felt overwhelming seem manageable and easy. The personal help made an especially strong impression. Marc and Yaro guided me through each stage, explaining the details clearly and making sure I felt confident before moving ahead. I never felt hurried or left unsure about what to do next. They patiently reassured me and shared their expertise throughout so I felt supported at every step. Having an accessible system alongside such a helpful support team is an uncommon combination. I'm very thankful for the guidance I received and would recommend Magicdoor to anyone seeking a reliable, professional and supportive solution. Marc and Yaro are a real asset to the company and their help made all the difference to my experience.
Cons
You can't easily point out anything wrong in this software, really!!
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
10
Functionality
9
Not Specified, N/A employees
“AI maintenance replies really help”
Pros
Managing four rental units as someone new to property management has been much easier than I expected with this software. Its interface is user friendly, even without much prior experience. The AI-generated replies to tenant maintenance requests are a standout for me, they save a lot of time and still come across as professional and helpful while I'm handling several tenants. Creating rental listings is simple too.. I set them up quickly and posted them on several online sites without hassle. Rent payment setup was also easy and stress-free. Having everything together in one place helps me stay organized and keep on top of things. The service being free is another plus. Overall, it's a useful, efficient tool for new property managers, with plenty of features that don't feel overwhelming. I'd recommend it to other small landlords and people starting out in property management.
Cons
All good, no cons from me
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“invoice options still need work”
Pros
A 3.5-star listing that continues to improve. This tool definitely has good potential
Cons
My main issue is how long it took for changes to be made, whether just for my platform or for all customers. I worked directly with Will Talku during onboarding in March 2025. Back then, the company had limited experience with commercial properties and how they differ from residential ones. I have 25 years of experience in both and I shared several major suggestions along with explanations. Will, the onboarding agent, agreed but it still took several months for changes to take effect. Yesterday, I sent an announcement and could clearly see a difference from two months ago, when an invoice could be sent by accidentally pressing enter before the context was finished. I gave feedback that sending a message should take two or more steps and suggested spellcheck though I'm not sure whether that was added. I also see that you took my suggestions or those from others and added the ability to create an invoice. That has helped with one-time bills but there's still no option to choose between one-time and recurring charges. I've worked with Haley several times over the past few months to set up recurring rent invoices. Each tenant has three charges and there wasn't a way to send an invoice for them. I've had to make invoices in Google Sheets for each unit which rather defeats my reason for using an online platform. I'll follow up with my rep to see whether this can be done.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
6
Value for money
5
Customer Support
7
Functionality
5
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Very attentive support”
Pros
David understands Magic Door software, listens carefully and offers exceptionally focused solutions that are easy to understand. Without his skills and personality, I might not have taken the step of becoming a Magic Door client.
Cons
I got no issues!!
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
9
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Magicdoor's perfect for property management”
Pros
Using Magicdoor has been enjoyable and Hailey has been very helpful whenever I've run into something. Those situations weren't really problems though, they came down to user error. The program is helping me manage my personal properties and I'm gradually starting to manage properties for other people too. I'm looking forward to seeing it grow with me and my business.
Cons
Everything was good, no cons heree
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
10
Functionality
9
Real Estate, 1-10 employees
Less than a year
“Responsive support and clear tracking”
Pros
Customer support team has been excellent! Professional, well informed and always ready to help. We've been using the service since last summer as beta users.
Cons
Once a tenant pays rent it's simple to keep track of the lease, payments and all communication in one place. I've been very happy with the platform overall.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“professional, responsive property management”
Pros
Working with David at Magic Door has been excellent... he's professional, quick to respond and truly committed to doing things properly. Property management feels simple and stress-free with him. Highly recommend!
Cons
Our experience was good, so nothing negative
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Perfect for remote management!!”
Pros
Managing properties remotely, I find this PMS tool excellent... really affordable, reliable and easy to use.
Cons
Dont have anything bad to say
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
9
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“helpful support and Zelle payments”
Pros
Support is prompt and genuinely helpful and the system is simple to use while still being customizable. It's also one of the few services that accepts Zelle. Onboarding and using the platform have been a very positive experience.
Cons
Good one! no complaints really
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Impressive”
Pros
Excellent for monitoring accounting across my real estate portfolio.. GI is exactly what I needed.
Cons
Haven't come across anything bad
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
9
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Made work easier”
Pros
I've used this software for the past few months and the team recently made some major accounting updates that were needed. The general ledger changes have made everyday reporting clearer and more useful. Having the option to use either cash or accrual accounting is a real benefit.. it gives the platform flexibility for different bookkeeping approaches and fits real-world property management workflows better. The software is still developing but updates come out quickly and issues are handled faster than I've seen with more established systems. Support is responsive and easy to work with. For a platform that listens, keeps improving quickly and takes modern accounting needs into account, MagicDoor is worth checking out.
Cons
Nothing comes to mind as a con.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“helpful system support”
Pros
Their rep Will helped me handle the issues I was facing. He knows the system and made everything clear and easy for me.
Cons
Everything worked well, so no downsides
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
10
Functionality
9
Not Specified, N/A employees
“complicated and unnecessary functions”
Pros
Wish i had something good to say but my experience was weird
Cons
I have worked with Magic Door for months now and up to now it has remained very complicated and not user-friendly. It has a lot of functions that aren't necessary for my use. I hope it will be better once they finish the program but I am looking for something else.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
3
Value for money
2
Customer Support
3
Functionality
2
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Communication tracking is amazing”
Pros
We can keep a closer eye on maintenance and communication with this tool. It's reliable and easy for everyday use.
Cons
You'll actually love it, it barely has a negative point
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Not Specified, N/A employees
“Helps with multilingual tenant communication”
Pros
I first managed my properties in Excel but soon saw that I needed software because I wasn't comfortable sharing my personal number and bank details with tenants. I tried Avil, Stessa and Doorloop, they were good but I wanted something easier to use. I joined MagicDoor as a beta customer last April and I'm happy with its features and customer support. It's easy to learn and use. I especially appreciate the multilingual communication which makes it easier to talk with tenants who don't speak English and helps improve tenant happiness and property occupancy.
Cons
Too good! No issues
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
9
Customer Support
10
Functionality
10
Real Estate, 1-10 employees
More than a year
“great AI automation for rentals”
Pros
Their AI automation has been a big help for me. It takes a lot of work off my plate especially with rent collection, tenant communication and managing maintenance requests.
Cons
A limitation is that the software is built for long term rentals and we are considering moving into the airbnb/short term rental space. I'd love to see them add support for short term rentals in the future.
Rating Distribution
Ease of use
10
Value for money
10
Customer Support
8
Functionality
8