Polymail

Polymail Reviews

Total 10 reviews

4.6

All reviews are from verified customers

Rating Distribution

5

Stars

70%

4

Stars

20%

3

Stars

10%

2

Stars

0%

1

Stars

0%

Satisfaction score

Ease of use

9

Value for money

9

Customer Support

9

Functionality

8

CC
Charlie C.

Internet, 11-50 employees

Less than a year

5.0

“Tracking and sequences worked well”

Pros

Keeping tabs on email engagement is really easy and I can also build sequences that track performance metrics across different clients.

Cons

One frustrating limitation is that once a sequence is created, it cannot be edited and there's no option to insert an email into the middle of an existing sequence.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

9

Value for money

10

Customer Support

9

Functionality

10

RK
Robert K.

Motion Pictures and Film, 1-10 employees

Less than a year

5.0

“Threaded conversations were absolutely fantastic”

Pros

One of the best things about it is the threaded conversation view. I am often part of long email chains and need to look back at something mentioned earlier and it makes that really simple, almost like scrolling through a text conversation.

Cons

The only downside I have noticed is that syncing can be a little slow sometimes. Emails usually show up in my regular inbox first and then appear in it a bit later. It doesn't happen often but it does happen occasionally.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

10

Value for money

9

Customer Support

10

Functionality

10

SP
Susan P.

Consumer Services, 11-50 employees

More than a year

5.0

“very friendly tool”

Pros

Using it has been a really positive experience. It's very user friendly, the initial setup is simple and it comes with plenty of features that make it a strong product. I especially like the settings that let me know when an email has been opened or when a document has been downloaded. They also keep updating the software and adding new features on a regular basis.

Cons

Honestly there isn't really anything I dislike about this software. A couple of people in our office use the upgraded version which includes additional features but that version does come at a cost while the standard version is free.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

10

Value for money

8

Customer Support

9

Functionality

8

MP
Megan P.

Marketing and Advertising, 1-10 employees

Less than 6 months

5.0

“5-star unified inbox sorting”

Pros

This is amazing. It pulls all my different email accounts into a single inbox, then lets me organize messages into categories so everything stays in one place.

Cons

Getting the most out of every feature took a little time to figure out but the site's helpful tips made learning it much more manageable.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

8

Value for money

10

Customer Support

10

Functionality

9

KH
Karen H.

Design, 1-10 employees

Less than 6 months

5.0

“inbox project management”

Pros

Polymail has a solid set of features that really push you to spend your time thoughtfully on your inbox. It's especially useful when multiple people are collaborating since it supports the kind of back-and-forth conversations that naturally come up around what's being sent. Overall, it feels like you can run lightweight project management directly from your email workflow.

Cons

The interface looks modern but it can still feel a bit cluttered particularly when I'm on a smaller laptop screen. It would be nice to be able to collapse some of the side panels to free up more room and at times the icons feel like they're doing a little too much making everything harder to scan.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

8

Value for money

8

Customer Support

10

Functionality

10

RT
Rigger T.

Graphic Design, 1-10 employees

Less than a year

4.0

“mass email customization”

Pros

It lets us customize how mass emails are sent and it's really effective for tracking so we can see what's happening with our messages across devices. Even though there are a lot of features, getting around on a device feels simple which helps when we're managing campaigns on the go.

Cons

A few of the plans are pricey when you compare them with other tools in the same category. There are also minor bugs from time to time and the interface layout can be a little confusing for people who are new to this kind of software.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

7

Value for money

7

Customer Support

9

Functionality

7

DMR
Daniel M. R.

Religious Institutions, 1-10 employees

More than a year

5.0

“monitors read receipts”

Pros

I'm really happy with how the app keeps everything organized especially since it syncs across all my devices automatically. It also makes it simple to monitor read receipts which helps me stay on top of conversations without constantly guessing.

Cons

Some features I'd love to use are locked behind the premium plan. That said they aren't deal-breakers and the core functionality still covers what I need day to day.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

10

Value for money

10

Customer Support

10

Functionality

9

A
Anonymous

Health, Wellness and Fitness, 500+ employees

Less than a year

5.0

“Salesforce synced communication”

Pros

Sales communication feels effortless and I really appreciate that it syncs with Salesforce. That connection makes it much easier to keep tasks organized and managed without juggling multiple systems.

Cons

Migrating from another tool can be a bit tricky especially if you're used to your own folder structure and workflows. It's an area that could use some improvement.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

10

Value for money

9

Customer Support

10

Functionality

8

A
Anonymous

Broadcast Media, 1-10 employees

More than a year

4.0

“Useful email tracking”

Pros

Its interface feels clean and genuinely pleasant for me to use. The standout feature is email tracking. It's been a real lifesaver for my sales workflow. Now I can tell when I'm just pinging a customer too often versus when the email hasn't been opened or even seen yet.

Cons

There are a handful of bugs though updates seem to roll in regularly. Since it's a paid email client, I do wish those issues were ironed out a bit faster.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

9

Value for money

10

Customer Support

8

Functionality

7

BO
Bernd O.

Photography, 1-10 employees

More than a year

3.0

“slow, glitchy UI”

Pros

Polymail has genuinely strong functionality. If you're on a subscription plan, you can see who opened your email and when, whether they clicked a link and even if they downloaded a file. That's really valuable for business workflows in my opinion. The campaigns and sequences also work well as a promotional tool since I can set them up to drive engagement over time.

Cons

The user interface feels anything but accessible. Key functions are difficult to locate and on top of that the app is pretty buggy. It sometimes seems like the team is more focused on shipping new features than making sure the basics are solid. A couple of concrete examples. You can't resize or scale images inside a message and if you send the message and view it in another email client, the images get distorted and stretched to the point of being unrecognizable. This should be disabled until it works properly. Also, images that I included in a campaign went missing by the time the sequence was actually sent to a large audience, meaning the system altered my message after I created it. That's a serious problem and definitely shouldn't have been released. There are also a lot of smaller UI glitches when importing and editing recipients for campaigns and sequences.

Rating Distribution

Ease of use

5

Value for money

5

Customer Support

5

Functionality

5