Solid Edge Reviews

Pros

I find the tools very easy to locate, and the visual hints provided are extremely helpful. The interface itself is exceptionally intuitive.

Cons

It uses more computational resources compared to other applications, but the trade-off is worth it.

Pros

Solid Edge is a CAD software that strikes the perfect balance between simplicity and advanced features. It is ideal for beginners due to its user-friendly interface and easy to learn features. Performing 2D to 3D designs is a so easy and simple. The software operates smoothly and swiftly which helps in efficient designing and modeling of parts and assemblies. Compared to other CAD software, Solid Edge is remarkably easy to use and learn. Its modeling features are undeniably impressive that eventually makes it a great choice for us.

Cons

I would like to see the introduction of more advanced features, similar to what we find in NX or Catia. Specifically, I am interested in advanced assembly mate features. I had difficulty assembling a complicated gear chain mechanism.

Pros

You can understand everything about this software pretty easily, thanks to its wonderful user interface and ease of use. It provides in-depth knowledge of product design and allows for real-time rendering of products. The option to modify parts easily and the overall interface contribute well to give you a fantastic user experience.

Cons

It responds slower compared to Solidworks.

Pros

It is highly useful and beneficial for engineers, especially when it comes to creating 2D and 3D drawings.

Cons

Occasionally, there are a few bugs when saving 2D drawings as PDF files.

Pros

This program offers countless features that meet and exceed expectations for a 3D modeling package. It allows the construction of complex models and the creation of assemblies to provide a comprehensive overview of projects or designs before physically bringing them to life.

Cons

Solid Edge is not the most intuitive software to learn and takes some time to become familiar with. Also it is not ideal for CAD beginners.

Pros

While sketching, I can apply geometry constraints, and I have the option to select the measurement standard prior to sketch creation. Moreover the recording feature is quite helpful for capturing workspace videos. Creating 3D drawings is a seamless process. Transforming 3D models into 2D sheets with detailed views is easily accomplished. The intelligent line selection feature proves beneficial when faced with challenging line selections in sketches.

Cons

We have to purchase the software from a reseller, and the customer support needs to improve their problem-solving skills. The software doesn't run smoothly on low-configured workstations. The user interface also needs improvement. Moreover, the software should not proceed to the next design steps if there are errors in the sketching process.

Pros

The ease of access is the most remarkable aspect of this software which makes it a truly excellent product.

Cons

Sometimes, I encounter bugs or glitches in the software, and certain tools don't function as described.

Pros

As an undergraduate student in design engineering, I can confidently say that Solid Edge is the best software for designing parts and assemblies.

Cons

For new users, initially it can be a bit confusing to identify the commands. Moreover there is a shortage of video tutorials available for this software.

Pros

Solid Edge allows me to achieve excellent results quickly, and making design changes with this software is incredibly simple. The user interface is clean and simple, eliminating the need to search through numerous buttons to find the desired function. The software excels at importing and exporting other CAD formats. Drawing options are impressive, enabling me to produce high-quality drafts in a short amount of time. Compared to other brands, Solid Edge is more powerful and stable, and the support staff in Australia is truly fantastic.

Cons

The installation and updates of the software can be quite troublesome and require technical assistance every time. For example whenever a new version is released, I have to spent at least a day to understand everything before I can resume working with it.

Pros

With Solid Edge, I can create custom parts and have them manufactured and shipped to me, with a wide range of materials to choose from. If you have a good understanding of the software, you can design vert complex objects by connecting part files.

Cons

Like any CAD program, there is definitely a learning curve, and it takes time for beginners to learn how to manipulate things according to their desired outcome. For instance, it took me a significant amount of time to figure out how to create a wire that corkscrews around a curved line. Even my teachers were unsure, so I had to watch numerous videos to get close to achieving what I wanted.

Pros

Normally, I use SolidWorks for 3D design, but when I needed to learn CNC, the instructor recommended using Solid Edge.

Cons

Personally, I didn't enjoy the 3D design aspect of it. When I tried it, it felt like I was transported back to the 1990s or something. Overall, I didn't like it at all.

Pros

Once you become proficient in operating this software, you can bring all your imaginative ideas to life. Solid Edge allows you to create stunning models and designs.

Cons

The software's user interface is quite messy which leads to boredom quickly. Also it is confusing and challenging to learn and operate.

Pros

Solid Edge allows you to do designing from scratch and you can easily end up with a fully-featured mechanical CAD design in just a few clicks. It is truly one of the best engineering CAD software available in the market. Oh, and the best part is that it's free for students and teachers!

Cons

Unfortunately, this software doesn't give you the option to perform Finite Element Analysis (FEA) or stress simulation. It would have been ideal if these features were integrated as an option to test the parts in real-time for their ability to withstand external forces.

Pros

The design options of this software are unbelievable. The ability to make modifications even after completing the entire 3D model is a major advantage of Solid Edge. When it comes to professional industrial tasks, Solid Edge is the most suitable software for the job.

Cons

As a beginner, I found it a bit challenging to work with, but it was still manageable for me. There were times when I had to search for specific command buttons, and getting familiar with the software wasn't easy.

Pros

Its user-friendly interface is gentle on the eyes as it gives a pleasant experience.

Cons

Some command buttons are not easily accessible and requires thorough exploration to find the hidden buttons.

Pros

Okay, so let me just clarify that my experience is based on the ST3 Version I used to have, not the new up-to-date version I now have, ST9. ST3's standout feature was undoubtedly its ability to assist our manufacturing shop with sheet metal work. I could create complex sheet metal parts with great accuracy. As sheet metal work often poses challenges, this software truly excels in that area.

Cons

Okay, so when I used the software, the most annoying thing was that when I created an assembly in the "ordered environment," all my features and assemblies were based on the parent sketch. As you know, designs evolve over time. So, when I made changes or updates to my sketch, my assembly either didn't update accordingly or more commonly, it would just break apart. This forced me to manually update it, resulting in hours of work. This issue particularly arose with large assemblies consisting of 12 or more parts.

Pros

Having the option between direct modeling and ordered modeling is perfect. This robust CAD tool offers numerous built-in advantages with their standard license, including FEA, data management, reverse engineering, generative design and advanced rendering with KeyShot.

Cons

Personally, I imagine this program being in the cloud eventually. I believe that's the direction the future is heading towards.

Pros

Solid Edge makes it easy to link the change process with PLM, which makes it one of the best software.

Cons

There is room for further improvement in the user interface's features.

Pros

It is easy for me to learn Solid Edge since I have a basic understanding of designing. I quickly understand all the software's features, and assembling CAD models is much more convenient compared to other software. The speed of this software is remarkable, allowing for rapid model design.

Cons

The 3D to 2D converter is decent, although it lacks certain features compared to other software of similar caliber. Additionally, the supported file formats are not as great as those offered by other software options. Moreover the user interface with its cramped menus is not very user-friendly.

Pros

In my six months of using Solid Edge, I have found it to be user-friendly when it comes to drawing 3D models. I saw its development in its early stages, and I am confident that it has significantly improved with additional features.

Cons

You may have to get additional training to fully learn the available features which requires time.