Scheduling, hiring, and compliance aren’t difficult because you lack skill; they’re hard because typical software isn’t built to manage the unpredictable challenges businesses face daily. If you’re in restaurants, hospitality, or retail, you know the drill: last-minute call-outs, constant turnover, and labor laws that change on a dime.

Both HotSchedules and PeopleMatter, offered by Fourth, are built to support those realities, but they do it in different ways.

HotSchedules excels in dynamic employee scheduling and labor optimization, making it a favorite among hospitality businesses like restaurants and hotels. Meanwhile, PeopleMatter focuses on streamlining high-volume hiring and onboarding, ideal for industries with frequent turnover, such as retail and quick-service restaurants.

In the sections ahead, we’ll compare both tools in detail, feature by feature, and you’ll also get an idea of what each one costs. So, if you genuinely want to know the difference between these two, keep reading.

HotSchedules Vs PeopleMatter: At A Glance

Features

HotSchedules

PeopleMatter

Workforce Management

Post-hire scheduling, shift planning, AI labor forecasting, and compliance alerts

Pre-hire focus with interview scheduling, onboarding tools, and E-Verify support

AI And Automation

AI-based shift forecasting, automated schedule creation, POS syncing, and inventory automation

AI for job ad targeting, pre-screening, interview scheduling, and automated onboarding workflows

Compliance And Reporting

Real-time scheduling compliance alerts, certification tracking, and detailed labor cost reports

Automated I-9s, E-Verify logs, and EEOC reporting for protected class data and hiring transparency

Financial Tools

Earned Wage Access via Fuego—employees access 50% of pay after each shift

Fuego Visa® Card for unbanked employees to receive digital pay during onboarding

Mobile Accessibility

Paid mobile app for shift swaps, time-off requests, and messaging (no clock-ins)

Mobile-optimized hiring flow only; native app sunset as of May 2024

Pricing

Estimated ~$40/location/month; 30-day free trial available; custom quotes from sales team

Quote-based pricing model; no public figures

What Is HotSchedules?

HotSchedules is a cloud-based workforce management platform primarily used for the hospitality, restaurant, and retail industries. However, its flexibility makes it suitable for any sector with shift-based scheduling needs.

One example of its impact can be seen with Bombshells Restaurant & Bar, a military-themed dining chain that previously relied on manual, paper-based scheduling processes. These outdated methods made it difficult to match staffing levels with real demand, resulting in inefficiencies and unnecessary labor costs. After implementing HotSchedules, Bombshells was able to reduce manual scheduling work by 20% and improve schedule accuracy by 50%.

This proves how tools like HotSchedules empower even the busiest operations to schedule quickly and accurately.

Standout Features Of HotSchedules

  • Drag-and-Drop Scheduling: Managers can create, move, and edit shifts directly on the scheduler using drag-and-drop functionality. You can also resize shifts by dragging their edges—all supported on both Classic and SmartView interfaces
  • Punch Clock: It includes a punch clock feature called Webclock for accurate time tracking, allowing managers to review, approve, and export timesheets for payroll processing
  • Alerts During Scheduling: If a manager attempts to create or modify a shift that violates any rule (e.g., missing break, pushing overtime, scheduling under-paid rate), the system will issue a toast pop-up and prevent saving until corrected

Pros And Cons Of HotSchedules

Pros

  • The Mobile app keeps you updated with instant schedule alerts
  • Offers detailed insights into sales performance and spending
  • Users can easily exchange or release shifts, which gives them more freedom and control over their schedules

Cons

  • Some users find it inconvenient that the mobile app requires a separate payment
  • Businesses may experience delays in support during critical system errors

What Is PeopleMatter

PeopleMatter is a comprehensive workforce management and applicant tracking software designed specifically for the hospitality, retail, and service industries. As part of the Fourth suite (like HotSchedules), it focuses on the entire employee lifecycle—from recruiting and hiring to onboarding and compliance.

It is widely used by multi-location businesses that rely on hourly staff and need to hire at scale. Take Southwest Georgia Oil, for instance: before PeopleMatter, their hiring process was a slow, paper-driven mess. After implementing it, they cut employee turnover by 57%, reduced onboarding time from 90 days to 54, and grew their annual applicant pool from 1,500 to over 12,000.

This proves that PeopleMatter solves the real hiring and onboarding challenges businesses deal with every day.

Standout Features Of PeopleMatter

  • Applicant Tracking System (ATS): PeopleMatter provides a robust, customizable ATS designed for high-volume, hourly hiring
  • Direct-To-Interview Scheduling: This feature allows applicants who pass pre-screening questions to automatically schedule interviews based on manager availability
  • Fuego Visa® Card Integration: The Fuego Visa® Card integration is primarily offered through PeopleMatter. It provides unbanked or underbanked employees a Visa debit card for wages, with benefits like early pay access (up to 2 days early), no fees, and fraud protection

Pros And Cons Of PeopleMatter

Pros

  • Users can easily manage and follow up on staff and applicants
  • Reports and information can be exported based on user needs
  • Adds a safety layer by checking applicant history directly within the system

Cons

  • There’s a recurring issue where applicants don’t receive initial emails unless they're resent
  • The software sometimes lags or becomes unresponsive

HotSchedules Vs PeopleMatter: Key Features Comparison

Workforce Management

HotSchedules specializes in managing employees after they’re hired. It offers tools for creating schedules using a drag-and-drop interface and AI-powered labor forecasting. Employees can request time off, and managers can approve it from mobile or desktop apps. One standout feature is the built-in compliance alerts—so if a schedule accidentally breaks labor rules (like overtime), managers get notified right away. HotSchedules makes it easy to run day-to-day operations smoothly and with fewer errors.

PeopleMatter, on the other hand, focuses on workforce management before hiring. It streamlines the interview stage with ‘Direct-to-Interview,’ which lets qualified candidates book interview slots automatically. After hiring, it supports onboarding and handles compliance tasks like E-Verify. However, it doesn’t offer post-hire scheduling tools.

Together, the two tools can connect to create a seamless hiring-to-scheduling workflow. Once a new hire completes onboarding in PeopleMatter, their information can flow directly into HotSchedules, where managers can immediately begin assigning shifts.

Winner: This one’s a tie because each platform serves a different stage of the employee journey—and both do it well.

AI And Automation

HotSchedules focuses on post-hire automation. It uses AI to forecast staffing needs by analyzing things like past sales, weather, and local events. Based on that, it automatically creates optimized shift schedules, helping managers avoid over- or understaffing. It also integrates with POS systems to adjust schedules in real time and alerts managers if any schedule breaks labor laws. For employees, HotSchedules offers self-service tools—like swapping shifts or requesting time off via mobile—and even sends automatic shift reminders. On the operations side, its integration with MacromatiX helps restaurants automate inventory and ingredient ordering based on sales forecasts, reducing food waste and improving stock accuracy.

PeopleMatter, meanwhile, brings automation to the hiring and onboarding process. Its AI tools automatically manage job ad placements to attract more applicants at a lower cost. It pre-screens candidates through custom questionnaires and instantly schedules interviews for those who qualify—cutting down hiring time dramatically. Once someone is hired, PeopleMatter automates onboarding tasks like tax paperwork and E-Verify checks. It also supports two-way SMS conversations with applicants, which helps reduce drop-off rates during hiring.

Winner: HotSchedules wins for delivering ongoing, operational automation. Its AI not only forecasts staffing needs but actively adjusts schedules and inventory in real time.

Compliance And Reporting

HotSchedules is built for post-hire compliance. It helps managers stay within labor laws by flagging violations in real time—like scheduling minors too many hours or breaking predictive scheduling rules. It tracks employee certifications, such as food safety licenses, and notifies managers before they expire.

On the payroll side, HotSchedules generates detailed reports that show hours worked, overtime, and job-specific labor costs, helping teams stay audit-ready. It also pulls in data from POS systems to compare sales with labor, preventing costly overstaffing. Managers can also access reports on staff availability to avoid scheduling conflicts and ensure agreements are honored. Even purchasing compliance is covered—its Program Compliance Report shows if managers are ordering from approved vendors or not.

PeopleMatter, in comparison, handles compliance during hiring and onboarding. It ensures each user has a unique login to meet E-Verify rules and tracks incomplete I-9s or pending verifications right from the dashboard.

All I-9 forms and E-Verify steps are automated, with full audit trails to support inspections. It also includes training modules for users to stay compliant with federal guidelines. Beyond that, PeopleMatter tracks protected class data—like veteran status or disabilities—to support equal opportunity reporting. For hiring analytics, it reports on candidate demographics and requisition statuses to help businesses maintain fair hiring practices.

Winner: HotSchedules handles compliance after hiring, while PeopleMatter focuses on getting everything right before the hire. Since both covers equally important stages, it’s a fair tie.

Financial Tools

HotSchedules integrates with Fuego’s Earned Wage Access system, which allows employees to withdraw up to 50% of their earned wages immediately after completing a shift. This amount is then automatically deducted from their next paycheck, just like a regular post-tax deduction. There’s no cost to the employer, and the process is fully integrated—employees simply log into HotSchedules to check their shifts and can instantly see how much money they’ve earned and how much is available for early access. This gives workers more financial flexibility, especially in industries with variable hours and tight cash flow between pay periods.

PeopleMatter, meanwhile, supports financial access at the onboarding stage, particularly for employees who may not have a traditional bank account. During the hiring process, PeopleMatter offers enrollment in the Fuego Visa® Card—a reloadable pay card that enables unbanked workers to receive their wages digitally. This card functions like a regular debit card, allowing employees to make purchases, withdraw cash, and manage their earnings without needing a bank.

Winner: Most people can live without a special pay card (they may already have one), but having early access to earned wages can make a real difference in daily financial health. Therefore, this round goes to HotSchedules.

Mobile Accessibility

HotSchedules provides a dedicated mobile app that employees can use to swap shifts, request time off, and message their team. The app gives staff more control over their schedules without needing to check in with a manager every time. The app requires a paid download (typically $2.99), and managers can make schedule edits on the go. However, it doesn’t include time-tracking—Clock-ins and outs are handled via a separate WebClock module, which is accessed through a web-based interface, not the mobile app.

PeopleMatter, in contrast, focuses its mobile features on the hiring and onboarding experience. It’s mobile-optimized for both job applicants and managers. Candidates can apply for jobs, complete screening steps, and even schedule interviews—all from their phones. However, as of May 2024, PeopleMatter officially sunset its mobile app. The app is currently no longer available in app stores, and the mobile app setting has been removed from the platform.

Winner: HotSchedules takes the win here. While its app isn’t free and doesn’t include time-tracking, it still offers a complete mobile experience with tools that frontline staff use daily.

What Is The Cost Of HotSchedules And PeopleMatter?

HotSchedules doesn’t list its pricing on the official website, so you’ll need to contact their sales team for a custom quote based on your business size and needs.

That said, third-party sources estimate the cost to be around $40 per location per month, and it also offers a 30-day free trial. On the other hand, PeopleMatter appears to follow a similar per-location pricing model, but no exact figures are publicly available. For accurate estimates, it’s better to reach out directly to the vendors or contact us for help.

Disclaimer: The pricing has been sourced from third-party websites and is subject to change.

Final Verdict: Which One Wins?

With three wins for HotSchedules and two tied categories, it’s clear that HotSchedules leads in overall functionality—especially when it comes to post-hire workforce management.

That said, since both HotSchedules and PeopleMatter are part of the Fourth ecosystem, they’re designed to complement each other rather than compete directly. PeopleMatter handles everything up to the point of hire—job ads, interview scheduling, onboarding, and compliance—while HotSchedules takes over from there with scheduling, labor forecasting, and shift management.

So, if your business needs a full hire-to-retire solution, combining both platforms gives you a seamless workflow.