Shift conflicts, missed shifts, and understaffing are common issues that arise when your human resources (HR) team schedules shifts without any dedicated tools. In 2022, around 37.4 million people left their jobs largely due to poor schedule flexibility and rising employee expectations. This shows the need for better scheduling tools to reduce turnover and improve satisfaction. 

However, these issues can easily be avoided by implementing scheduling software like When I Work and NimbleSchedule, which are designed to streamline HR tasks and shift management. When I Work helps businesses schedule shifts and track time effectively. On the other hand, NimbleSchedule is a more comprehensive platform offering features for scheduling, time tracking, payroll, and more. 

In this When I Work vs NimbleSchedule guide, we have compared both platforms in detail to help you choose the one that solves your unique problems. 

When I Work Vs NimbleSchedule: At A Glance

Features

When I Work 

NimbleSchedule 

Scheduling 

Comprehensive dashboards and shift swaps 

Recurring schedules and open shifts 

Time And Attendance 

‘Geo Fencing’ and ‘Photo Clock In’ 

Badge proximity entry and ‘Group Punch’ 

Integrations 

Supports 15+ integrations, including People, GoCo, and Gusto 

Offers 320+ integrations, including Listo, OurPeople, and Nectar HR 

Reporting 

Pre-built reports, shift templates, and custom shift reports 

Paycor’s AI assistant and a variety of reports 

Job Costing 

Weekly shift limits and ‘Early Clock In Prevention’ 

Various labor code categories and ‘Overtime Insights’ 

What Is When I Work?

When I Work is a shift scheduling software that helps organizations streamline employee scheduling and time tracking. Due to its versatility, it can be implemented in a number of industries, including restaurants, hospitality, healthcare, and retail. Moreover, businesses can leverage this tool to save time and ensure staffing needs are met, supplementing growth and productivity. 

Unique Features Of When I Work 

  • Pay Period Forecast: Allows organizations to forecast budget for an ongoing payroll cycle by factoring in metrics like employee working hours, leaves, and overtime
  • Photo Clock In: Prevents buddy clock ins only when employees take a picture of themselves
  • Tips Tracking: Allows employees to record and track their tips directly in the system
  • Workplace Announcements: Enables administration to send important messages and updates to everyone in the organization instantly through the platform

Pros And Cons Of When I Work 

Pros: 

  • It’s easy to schedule employees for different shifts and in different locations 
  • Employees can easily view their scheduled shifts using mobile devices 
  • Enables managers to effectively and clearly communicate with individual employees or with teams 

Cons: 

  • It doesn’t allow administrators to copy employee shifts, meaning they have to create new ones in some cases 
  • Sometimes, it restricts employees to view open shifts, and there are no weekly reminders for available shifts 

What Is NimbleSchedule?

NimbleSchedule, now known as Paycor software, is an all-in-one human capital management (HCM) solution that enables businesses to streamline employee scheduling, payroll, time tracking, talent acquisition, and more. It’s geared toward all sizes of businesses and is used in industries like healthcare, retail, education, and non-profit. 

Unique Features Of NimbleSchedule 

  • Payroll Management: Helps businesses streamline payroll calculations, compliance, and tax filing
  • Benefits Administration: Simplifies benefits administration with automated enrollment alerts, custom workflows, and detailed reporting
  • Recruiting: Enables recruiters to hire better talent with AI-powered job descriptions, interview scorecards, and candidate dashboards
  • Onboarding: Allows organizations to structure their onboarding process by eliminating paperwork and synchronizing new hire data with the platform’s broader solutions

Pros And Cons Of NimbleSchedule 

Pros: 

  • Its chat feature helps a lot in ensuring effective and productive communication among employees 
  • Individuals can add pages to favorites using different tabs on the website, allowing them to easily access information that’s used frequently 
  • The platform makes it easy for employees to view open shifts and the locations they are available in 

Cons: 

  • Users get logged out if they become inactive for a while, meaning they’ll have to log in all over again 
  • The ‘Transfer Employee’ button doesn’t transfer all the information, and managers have to do it manually 

When I Work Vs NimbleSchedule – Key Features Comparison

Scheduling

When I Work offers a comprehensive dashboard that comes with a drag-and-drop option, making the process easy. Managers can quickly create shifts, recurring schedules, and integrate notifications and calendars to ensure there are no shift conflicts. It also lets employers post open shifts while employees can easily claim them using their mobile devices, ensuring staffing requirements are always met.

The platform also allows employees to trade and swap shifts with their colleagues, giving them more freedom and fostering a more flexible and employee-friendly environment. Furthermore, its scheduling system can be used to schedule team training, making it a versatile option for organizations.

NimbleSchedule also offers a comprehensive dashboard that lets managers easily manage employee shifts. Managers can create recurring schedules, weekly templates, and copy-and-paste shifts. These features can help lessen the stress that managers often face when dealing with a large workforce and simplify their workflow.

With its self-service features, employees can easily view their vacation requests and available time off, swap shifts, pick open shifts, and set their availability. These tools ultimately reduce the back-and-forth between employees and HR while simplifying the whole scheduling process.

Winner: When I Work wins due to its employee-friendly features and flexible scheduling options, such as scheduling team training.

Time And Attendance

When I Work makes it easy for employees to clock in and clock out. If an employee tries to clock in on a day they are not scheduled, the system informs them and prevents inaccurate clock-ins. The software empowers businesses to convert a range of devices, including iPads, mobiles, desktops, and POS systems, into time clocks. This flexibility allows organizations to utilize their existing hardware instead of buying new hardware.

It offers ‘Geo Fencing’ and ‘Photo Clock In’ technology, preventing off-site and buddy check-ins. Managers are also equipped with tools to clock employees in and out if they forget, ensuring employees are credited for the work they are putting in. Additionally, timesheets can be easily exported, helping businesses accurately calculate payroll while staying compliant with local labor laws.

NimbleSchedule offers a comprehensive dashboard that displays time off requests, employee working hours, and check-ins all in one place, simplifying time and attendance tracking. The software provides several time clock options, such as badge proximity entry, PIN entry, and geo-fencing capabilities, helping employees register their time conveniently and on time.

Administrators can use the ‘Group Punch’ feature to submit group punches from their mobile devices, saving time and eliminating chances of error. Furthermore, its built-in alerts notify employees and admins of any discrepancies in the time data, ensuring employees are paid fairly, and businesses stay compliant with labor laws.

Winner: When I Work wins again as it offers ‘Photo Check In’ features and the ability to convert a number of devices into time clocks.

Integrations

When I Work offers 15+ integrations for payroll and other business operations with popular platforms. These include Square Payroll, Gusto HR software, GoCo, and People. Organizations can utilize these integrations to extend and enhance the software’s capabilities.

NimbleSchedule supports integration with 320+ third-party applications and tools. Some of the supported platforms include Listo, Tilt, Nectar HR, Mitratech, and OurPeople. Organizations can choose applications based on their specific needs and significantly enhance the platform’s capabilities.

Winner: NimbleSchedule wins as it offers 320+ integrations with a wide range of third-party applications and software.

Reporting

When I Work equips businesses with an array of reports to help them analyze data and make informed decisions. It offers pre-built reports for employee absences, attendance notices, schedules, shift requests, shift templates, time-off requests, and more. It also provides managers with tools to create custom shift reports, times reports, and shift history reports.

NimbleSchedule allows businesses to analyze data for a broader range of metrics like employee headcount, compensation, retention, and resignations. Its customization tools enable organizations to gather frequently used reports in one space, making them accessible.

Moreover, Paycor’s AI assistant provides businesses with data-backed answers to their queries, enabling decision-makers to improve processes and address issues more effectively. However, some users have reported issues with its reporting tools, such as minor inaccuracies and glitches.

Winner: When I Work wins as it’s a more reliable platform for getting reports right for scheduling and time tracking despite having no AI-backed insights.

Job Costing

When I Work helps track labor costs with its labor distribution reports, allowing them to keep track of their expenditure in accordance with project budgets. Administrators can set pay rates for each position and weekly shift limits, helping them save time while adhering to their budget constraints.

Additionally, its ‘Early Clock In Prevention’ feature prevents employees from checking in early, which ensures there are no unnecessary labor costs.

NimbleSchedule allows managers to set various labor code categories that are related to their organizations, facilitating accurate projects and time tracking. This helps businesses analyze how many resources are being allocated to specific tasks and initiatives and cut costs where possible.

With its detailed ‘Overtime Insights, ' companies can break down their spending by location, manager, and department, allowing them to calculate costs more accurately.

Winner: It’s a tie as both software programs offer unique features that are valuable for job costing.

Final Verdict – Which HR Software Is Better?

Both software programs are great at time tracking and employee scheduling. However, they have unique capabilities that make them more suitable for solving different business needs. 

When I Work offers excellent tools to streamline scheduling and automate HR tasks. It’s a good option, especially for companies that don’t want to spend a lot on attendance hardware, as it allows them to convert their existing devices into fully functional time clocks. NimbleSchedule, on the other hand, provides extensive integration and payroll capabilities along with employee scheduling and time tracking, making it a better choice for organizations looking for a comprehensive solution. 

In the end, the better software between When I Work vs NimbleSchedule will be the one that solves your specific problems. We recommend discussing the options with stakeholders and consultants to ensure you purchase the right software.