Basecamp Vs. Monday.com: Which Is Better?
Project management is no mean feat—it's an art that demands that everything be firing on all cylinders all the time. To ensure this, project managers must make sure that all aspects of the project are optimized for the tasks at hand. One of these aspects is the tools used for the project. Make no mistake—the right tools significantly enhance productivity, streamline workflows, and improve collaboration among team members.
The two best project management software options are Basecamp and Monday.com. Both platforms offer essential task management features but take different approaches to cater to various needs and preferences.
Hence, Software Finder has curated this comparison between Basecamp and Monday.com, highlighting their key features and comparing them against different benchmarks. By the end of this article, you can make an informed decision about which tool is the best fit for your project.
Features | Basecamp | Monday.com |
User Interface | Clean and minimalist UI that even non-technical users can navigate through | An intuitive UI that can be customized based on the customer’s needs |
Customizability | Offers limited customization options to create a more streamlined approach | Offers a high degree of customization, allowing users to create custom boards, fields, and workflows |
Project View | Lacks project views, but does offer a custom Kanban view | Offers a multitude of project views (Kanban, Calendar, Workload, etc.) |
Collaboration Tools | Built-in chat, file sharing, and an announcement board | Messaging, comments, file sharing, and team boards |
Reporting Tools | Activity logs, task completion rates, and project timelines | Formula columns, customizable dashboards, and chart views |
Integrations | Integrates with a number of third-party tools such as Field Trip, AssessTeam, ZohoFlow, etc. | Wide variety of integrations with popular software such as Gmail, Microsoft Teams, Slack, etc. |
Project Templates | Lacks pre-built templates but allows you to make your own | Comes with over 200+ pre-built templates |
Add buttons in last row |
|
|
Basecamp Software is a popular project management tool known for its simplicity and ease of use. While it is a little bare in features compared to its peers, Basecamp makes up for it by focusing on essential project management features like to-do lists, scheduling, and communication. This single-minded approach focuses on the core concepts of collaborative project management, making Basecamp widely accessible among users.
To further help with accessibility, Basecamp sports a clean, minimalist interface that is less cluttered than its peers, making it easier to navigate. Thus, its simplicity and ease of use make it ideal for smaller teams or non-technical users who prefer a simpler interface.
Basecamp Key Features
Key features of Basecamp include:
- Minimalist interface that’s easy to navigate and use
- Built-in to-do list that keeps track of progress and sets due dates
- Real time group chat
- Cloud storage that facilitates collaboration on project files
- A custom Kanban view that keeps things simple
Pros
Simplicity
Basecamp's minimalist interface makes it easy to learn and use, even for non-technical users. Its prioritization of core features like to-do lists, calendars, messaging, and file sharing makes it ideal for teams that prefer a minimalist approach. It is also a good choice for teams wanting to save time during the initial setup, getting the system up and running as soon as possible.
Focus on Communication
The software emphasis on collaboration between team members helps create an environment where team members frequently communicate, share, and stay aligned on project goals. Features such as the chat, message board, and comments help reinforce this approach.
Reliability
Basecamp’s focus on essential features helps keep it focused, unlike other software that hastens to add all kinds of bells and whistles and falls victim to feature bloat. Its inherent simplicity keeps the software reliable in terms of performance, ensuring that there are no bugs because of frequent updates.
Cons
Limited Customization
Compared to other project management tools, Basecamp offers fewer customization options. This can be a limitation for teams with complex workflows or specific requirements, making it harder to recommend Basecamp to larger teams with more extensive projects.
Lack Of Advanced Features
Basecamp may not offer all the advanced features some teams may need, such as built-in Gantt charts, time tracking, or resource management. Its reporting features are also relatively limited compared to other platforms, making it difficult to generate detailed analytics.
A powerful project management system, Monday.com Software offers a host of features, such as CRM tools and pre-built solutions for product development. It also acts as a work OS—software that integrates apps so that all the work can be put under one umbrella, making it ideal for cross-departmental communication.
Unlike Basecamp, Monday.com offers a more flexible approach and a customizable framework for its users, allowing them to create tailored workflows. This degree of customization makes Monday.com a popular choice for teams seeking a flexible and efficient work management solution.
Monday Key Features
Some of Monday.com’s key features are:
- Customizable dashboards that offer several views (Kanban, Calendar, Workload, etc.)
- An intuitive interface that’s easy for users to learn and use
- Pre-built solutions and integrations
- Automation of repetitive tasks that save time
- Collaboration tools such as task assignment, comments, and real-time updates
Pros
Customizable Workflows
The ability to customize workflows according to your every whim makes Monday.com stand out from its competitors. Specifically, tailored workflows help teams streamline processes, reduce errors, and enhance decision-making. This customizability also applies to many areas such as creating a sales pipeline, project management, marketing campaigns, and HR processes.
Advanced Reporting
Monday.com offers a holistic and up-to-date view of the project. It does this by automatically updating dashboards when changes to the source data occur. This, combined with automated notifications, streamlines task handoffs and eliminates the need to manually request reports from other departments.
Seamless Integrations
Monday.com boasts a large number of integrations with many third-party software such as Slack, Gmail, Microsoft Teams, Outlook, GitLab, and so many more. This versatility allows Monday.com to fit into almost any workflow and keep the cost of setting it up to a minimum.
Cons
Limited Mobile App Functionality
While Monday.com offers a mobile app, its functionality is somewhat limited. Users cannot create, edit, or even open documents such as PDF and Word files.
Lack Of Certain Quality of Life (QoL) Features
Despite Monday.com’s overwhelming list of features, it curiously lacks a few basic QoL features found in other software. Users have to switch between views to access subitems, cannot use wrap text for any attribute, and cannot rearrange items in automation without deleting it first. All these contribute to making the software a little cumbersome and unwieldly.
Here, we will showcase how to set up a project in Basecamp and Monday software, so that their differences are more apparent.
Basecamp
Starting a project in Basecamp is relatively straightforward: just click on the “Make a new project " button, fill in the relevant details, and you’re good to go.
Once the project file is made, you can navigate around six key features of Basecamp: the Message Board, To-dos, Card Table, Docs & Files, Chat, and Schedule. With the help of these features, you can get started on your project. However, customization options are limited; what you see is pretty much what you get.
Monday Software
Starting a project is also simple for Monday software; however, the UI is a bit more complicated and requires more navigation than Basecamp. Users can get started by clicking on the “+” icon in the left ribbon and selecting the item they want to make from the drop-down menu.
This way, users can create boards, documents, forms, or any item their workspace needs. They can also customize these items in any way that they fit. In addition, users can use project views to gain additional insights about the project. However, users may need some time to familiarize themselves with this platform's inner workings.
Both Basecamp and Monday software excel in project management; however, they both have various strengths and drawbacks. Therefore, it is imperative for any organization to compare software so that it knows which one best fits its needs.
1. Pricing Plans
Basecamp
Basecamp is a great fit for individuals and small companies. It offers a 30-day free trial period so that users can see for themselves how the software works. However, the paid tiers list more add-ons than the trial version.
Currently, there are two pricing plans offered by Basecamp:
- Basecamp - $15/user/month
- Basecamp Pro Unlimited - $349/month (Unlimited Users)
Disclaimer: Pricing is subject to change
Monday
Like Basecamp, Monday.com offers a limited trial period during which users can test the product for themselves. Unlike Basecamp, Monday software offers more pricing plans, allowing businesses of all sizes to pick a specific tier that perfectly fits their project.
Monday.com offers the following pricing plans:
- Free - $0 (Up to 2 Seats)
- Basic - $12/seat/month
- Standard - $14/seat/month
- Pro - $24/seat/month
- Enterprise - Custom Pricing
Disclaimer: Pricing is subject to change
Winner: There is no “right” choice here, as it all depends on your organizational needs and the scope of the project. Monday.com is a better fit for larger teams that deal with more complicated projects; however, smaller teams with simpler projects may find Basecamp more suited to their needs.
2. Customization
Basecamp
Due to Basecamp’s ethos of keeping things simple, it does not offer much in terms of customization and templates. While there are limited options for customization, such as custom fields and views, ultimately, Basecamp has a fixed structure when it comes to creating a workflow.
Monday
One of Monday’s unique selling points is its high level of customizability. Users can create custom dashboards with different views (Kanban, Calendar, Workload, etc.) and add specific fields and automation to help create the workflow they desire.
Winner: The clear winner here is Monday. However, for smaller teams that do not require customization, Basecamp offers a clearer, streamlined approach.
3. User Interface
Basecamp
Basecamp is known for its relatively simple and clean interface compared to its peers. Since the software focuses on project management essentials, the UI has almost no clutter and is easy to understand and use. However, it does not offer many project views as a trade-off for this simplicity.
Monday
Monday’s UI is intuitive, with eye-catching buttons. However, unlike Basecamp, its UI is more cluttered and a bit more complex to navigate properly. However, Monday offers the ability to customize your interface and comes with several project views and options.
Winner: Ultimately, the best UI for your team depends on your specific needs and preferences. Monday may be a better fit if you prefer a more customizable and feature-rich interface. If you value simplicity and ease of use, Basecamp's cleaner UI might be more appealing.
4. Collaboration And Communication Tools
Basecamp
Basecamp comes with several collaboration features, such as built-in chat, file sharing, comments, and an announcement board that broadcasts important messages to the entire team. This focus on messaging and comments helps create a more focused experience compared to other software.
Monday
Similar to Basecamp, Monday offers essential collaboration features such as comments and file sharing; however, it also offers a lot more depth to those features. For example, comments can tag other team members with direct notifications.
Winner: Monday has a clear advantage over Basecamp here as their additional features can provide a more dynamic experience. However, anyone looking for an experience with just the essentials may find Basecamp more suited to their needs.
5. Cross-Departmental Communication
Basecamp
As mentioned, Basecamp offers collaboration features such as comments and chats, which are also used to help communicate between departments. Additionally, Basecamp’s focus on projects means that most communication takes place while working on projects, removing unnecessary noise and distractions that may occur.
Monday
Monday offers a board structure that can be used to visualize and manage cross-departments, making it easier to see how other projects are coming along. Automation can also be set up to trigger notifications or otherwise update members when certain events occur. Finally, Monday’s various integrations can help connect different departments (such as HR systems).
Winner: Monday’s integrations and board structure give it the upper hand over Basecamp in terms of different communication methods.
6. Project Templates
Basecamp
Unlike its peers, Basecamp does not offer any pre-made templates. However, this does not mean it has no template function as Basecamp allows users to create and save templates from existing projects. This feature allows users to create multiple projects with the same structure, saving them time and effort.
Monday.com
Monday.com offers more than 200 pre-made templates. These templates are designed to cater to various industries and specific use cases. Additionally, all these templates are customizable and provide a great jumping point for users to create their own workflows.
Winner: Once again, Monday.com is the clear winner here—their sheer number of templates that pertain to a variety of topics make them an ideal choice compared to Basecamp.
7. Reporting and Analytics
Basecamp
In terms of reporting, Basecamp offers useful features such as activity logs, task completion rates, project timelines, etc. Despite having limited customization, it does allow its users to create custom reports depending on certain criteria.
Monday
By contrast, Monday offers much more advanced reporting features, such as customizable dashboards, chart views, and various graphs. They also take it a step further and give users the ability to visualize data in various formats to gain insight into various metrics, such as project progress, team progress, etc. Integration with analytical software such as Google Analytics helps provide a more nuanced analysis.
Winner: In summary, Monday's reporting and analytics capabilities are generally more advanced and customizable than Basecamp. However, Basecamp's basic reporting features may be sufficient for teams that don't have extensive analytics needs.
8. Integrations
Basecamp
Basecamp offers integrations with a wide variety of third-party tools such as Field Trip, AssessTeam, Zoho Flow, etc. However, one important thing to note is that while Basecamp does not have direct integrations with popular software such as Slack, it does offer integrations with software that facilitate that integration (for example, Field Trip can be used to share Basecamp activity in Slack).
Monday.com
By contrast, Monday offers direct integrations with popular software like Slack and Microsoft Teams. Additionally, the software acts as a hub for those integrations, allowing users to access everything in one place.
Winner: The sheer breadth of Monday’s software integrations and ease of setup make it a clear winner.
9. Security
Basecamp
Basecamp includes standard data encryption procedures, such as data encryption and two-factor authentication. The software also undergoes regular security audits that identify and address potential vulnerabilities.
Monday
Like Basecamp, Monday adheres to all standard data procedures and offers two-factor authentication as an additional layer of security. It is also certified to comply with various security standards, such as ISO 27001.
Winner: Both software are equally matched when it comes to security risks.
10. Customer Support
Basecamp
Basecamp’s primary mode of support is through email and live chats. Their website also lists a resource center with articles, software tutorials, and FAQs that help users troubleshoot problems.
Monday
Monday also offers support through email, live chats, and a website with tutorials on getting the software working. Due to Monday’s popularity, many user-created tutorials on YouTube can help users find their way through even niche problems that even the official website has not covered.
Winner: Overall, both Basecamp and Monday have solid customer support options. However, individual experiences may vary depending on factors such as the complexity of the issue and the availability of support staff.
The primary difference between Basecamp and Monday is complexity—Basecamp’s ethos revolves around making things as accessible as possible, thus creating a focus on essential features even at the cost of more fancy bells and whistles. Meanwhile, Monday’s goal is to deliver a work OS that can be customized however the user sees fit. Therefore, this software is more feature-rich and complex to navigate.
While our comparisons have shown that Monday comes out ahead due to the extensive features it offers, the increased complexity, combined with a lack of certain QoL features, may not make it applicable to smaller teams with simpler projects.
In the end, it all depends on the user and their needs. If the users prioritize simplicity and ease of use, Basecamp might be the better option. However, if users require more advanced features and customization, Monday.com may be a better fit.
If neither software fits your specific requirements, it’s best to look for more alternatives. Platforms such as Asana Software and Trello Software are project management tools that offer comparable features while offering unique strengths. Exploring these alternatives may help you find the right tool for your workflow.
